Each little horse is made from felt with a tail and mane made from thread and a couple of googly eyes. The little coats are piece of wide ribbon and the hooves are black card. I didn't have any grey thread for the grey horse so I used white and a black pen to give it grey streaks (he is my favourite!)
Each horse has a little number on his coat (written on a circle of card from a hole punch with a gold pen) which make his birthday. I'm sure no one will notice, but it's there.
They are mounted, along the the letters, onto acetate with a cloud background so they get some nice shadows. The trophy is just thick foil with 65 written with an black OHP pen.
I don't think he is much of an Internet surfer so I don't suppose this will spoil the surprise. I hope he likes it and has a lovely birthday.